Help Advice for Tactics

[Alexei1210]

So I've cooked up two 5 back or 3-2 back tactics and was wondering which one would be most suitable to make adjustment if necessary and build around.
Tactic #1:

So the idea of this tactic is based around counter-play:

• Me personally, I find a decent amount of strikers on the market currently are not very aerially dominant so I think that attacking mentality + high press would enable a sort of gegenpress? And after the ball is won back, direct passing and through balls would go to decently paced attackers so that they would score.
• I go for passing focus on both flanks because my midfield is non-existence so why bother? The idea is that the BWM would go for duels to win the ball back, pass it to the 2nd CM (I'm contemplating between RP or DLP for this, I'm going for RP right now so that he can support the forwards if necessary, as I feel that DLP would take time to go forward which loses attacking momentum).
• WBs pushing forward overlapping with IFs to hit low crosses at the edge of the box if necessary and player marking to force them into defensive duties, avoiding space in behind for the opponent to run into.
• Expressive freedom so that they can swap places with each other or go for risky passes/dribbles

Tactics #2:

This tactic would still be based on the prior, but a more balanced approach:

• 3-4 in the back for solidity in defense, AP would enable passing options or support the pushing RP and the SS + CF would press the opposition and score goals.
• Short passes and Mixed focus because now I have a midfield to play around and distribute the ball.
• GK distribution is me messing around seeing which is better in which scenarios so not that important.

And that's that, thank you for bearing with me and my tactics, this is my first time actually working to make a tactic so any suggestions would help me a lot, thank you